Car Insurance Accident Scams

Many car accidents are just insurance scams that consumers end up paying for through higher premiums.

You’re driving down the street or a highway or freeway and are suddenly involved in an accident. Not just any accident, but a carefully orchestrated and scripted accident where you become the victim of a scheme to dupe your insurance company out of thousands of dollars.

Each year, all over America, insurance companies spend millions of dollars guarding themselves against misleading car accident claims. These statements are perpetrated by individuals looking to reap the benefits of these false insurance claims.

How are you affected by these auto insurance scams? Who pays for the real cost of auto insurance fraud? I’ll give you a hint…it’s not the insurance companies.

Sure, initially they pay, but then they turn around and jack up everyone else’s insurance premiums to make up for the loss. It’s an adverse outcome for sincere citizens.

What these auto insurance scams can cost you

Record Tarnished – This is when a perpetrator reports a factious hit and run to their insurance provider

Image car accident insurance scam

Victims Intimidated and/or Killed – Staged accidents for insurance claims are hazardous to your health. It’s a small mistake, by you as the victim and/or by the perpetrators, that could end your life or the lives of your loved ones.

Premiums increased – Insurance agencies pass the cost of phony insurance claims on to everyone else in their customer base. It’s not in the company’s best interest to absorb them. Why should they? There’s no law that states they’re responsible.

Types of auto insurance accident scams

Most cons are performed by professionals who run rehearsals before really committing the crime. They are usually very skilled at their trade, but that does not mean you can’t take steps to prevent yourself from becoming a victim.

So, what can you do to help yourself and all the other honest insurance premium payers? First, learn about the most common car accident traps carried out today. If you think you’ve witnessed a scam or are being scammed, contact you insurance provider immediately.

Keep a disposable camera, paper and pen in your glove department. Pictures can be invaluable when trying to protect yourself after an accident has taken place. Take many pictures of all the cars involved, including the passengers.

Record as much information as you can about each participant in the accident, including witnesses. With pictures and extensive documentation, this shouldn’t leave any room for the scammers to lie about damages to their persons and/or vehicle.

The following is a list of some of the most common rip-off techniques put into practice.

Paper Accident – This occurs when a criminal aggressively requests others in the auto repair and salvage industry to be a part of accidents that only exist on paper. Sometimes the con will include crooked lawyers, doctors and insurance agents.

Most insurance companies don’t investigate claims under $1,000. As a result, these claims are almost always below that amount so as not to arouse suspicion.

Hit & Run – Happens when a swindler reports a fake hit and run accident to their insurance provider.

Swoop & Squat – This tactic is employed by a planner who suddenly swoops in front of a car and quickly squats or stops. An accessory moves to the side of the besieged victim to keep the trapped car from swerving out of the way.

The passengers in the car that abruptly put itself in front of the victim’s all claim injuries that are later supported by a doctor or a chiropractor in cahoots with the others involved in the scam.

Sideswipe – The same as it sounds. Where there’s a multiple turn lanes at an intersection, be on the lookout for someone who takes a left turns until another car swiftly maneuvers into the lane whereas the perpetrator suddenly speeds up to force a collision.

T-Bone – Carefully planned, this tactic usually conducted when there isn’t anyone around who could counteract the eyewitness accounts of bogus witnesses. The scammer waits at an intersection until a car comes along and deliberately rams into it as the car passes.

After the police arrive, phony witnesses (who were waiting nearby) tell the police officer the victim improperly ran a stop sign or red light.

Wave – Used when there’s a lot of traffic with a driving situation that includes a merge and/or “right of way”. Feigning politeness, the scam artist waves to the victim, indicating that they’re yielding the right of way to them.

As the victim begins to go, the scam artist rapidly accelerates to cause an accident. When police arrive, the perpetrator rejects the victim’s assertion that they gave up the right of way to them.

Shady Helper – This could happen after an honest accident. A stranger approaches you after an accident and offers numbers to an auto repair shop, lawyer or doctor.

This could be a setup.

The auto repair shop often pads your repair cost, and a doctor may give you shady treatment or none at all. A lawyer may even try to convince you to sue the insurance company.

What to do if involved in an Automobile Accident

Exchange information with the person driving the vehicle, including:

  • Drivers license data
  • Vehicle registration
  • Proof of insurance

Count the number of people in the car and for each one get their:

  • Name
  • Address
  • Telephone Number

Call the police if it seems staged!

Make notations regarding seatbelts. Where they wearing them? After the police arrived, did they act injured, when they seemed perfectly fine beforehand?

Treat witnesses the same as if they were involved. Record their names, addresses, phone numbers and get confirmation that they would be willing to sign a statement.

If anything seems remotely “hinky”, call the police! Don’t get conned into not calling them by the other parties involved.

Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
7 years ago

I was fraudulently accused of hit and run in a parking lot. While working in a nearby shop,police cMe and were looking for someone I asked who he gave my name. He said someone witnessed me hitting a car while parking then leaving. I told him that I never parked next to the van and had been parked all morning in my own spot which was across the lot from him. I even had a witness . The cop said there were scratches on both cars that matched up . He said he measured them but would not give me the measurements . He forced me to give him information otherwise would arrest me for hit-and-run . Test to be a scam there are no scratches on the car there was something that look like white wax and I don’t think it would have lined up to my car because of the angle of my fender would not have collided with the angle of his fender but the cop would not let me put my car next to his daily The potato did not have a license plate because he said it was a new vehicle I took a picture of it he so-called scratch and his face the police didn’t like that. He said he had a witness that saw it happened but didn’t know who he was or where he went. The manager of the restaurant where he came from did not see anything happen I just repeated what the person said I did . I was parked at 10 AM in the same spot where he said the accident occurred at 11:04 I wasn’t even moving my car at that time I was at work but the copper not believe me they were five witnesses at work where I was I could prove I was there and the police did not care
I went to the police station to report what happened and he came out with a different partner not the one who was with them. I think they might be both in on this scam???

D. B
6 years ago
Reply to  Darci

Sounds like a scam to me. Stick with the truth and hire a good lawyer. Write down everything, document every little detail. Take pictures when possible. Best of luck.

Donna Orsino
5 years ago

Last year, in Oct/Nov, 2017, I was hit by a large white van while he was pulling out of the parking spot next to mine in Beverly Hills, Florida. My car is just a little Scion. I was not in the car but standing with the passenger door open looking for something in the car, when all of a sudden the door shut on me. I yelled at the guy telling me he could have killed me. So… he pulled back in the parking spot, got out and talked to me. We both had the same insurance company (State Farm). Shortly after that he got back in his van and locked the door, made a phone call and would not comment when I tried to get his attention. There were no witnesses and I did not call the police because he seemed to be an honest man, telling me how he wanted to make this right and that he wanted to do what he could so I was not implicated. IMPLICATED for what? He told the insurance company that we were both pulling out of the parking spaces at the same time. FUNNY, but I can’t see how that is possible if I was not in the car. My insurance went up, so I got another insurance company, Progressive. Moving a little forward…. Progressive dropped me after calling for a tow or some other road side assistant for either a flat tire or breaking down on the road. The man at progressive tried to tell me that they do that when a client is a bad risk. A BAD RISK for getting a flat or breaking down. How is that possible. He said if clients have a habit of driving in an unsafe place they are considered a risk. I won’t go any further with this. I am on SS and it is my only income. I tried to get another insurance company that wanted over $200 a month for a premium. Then I tried Progressive again… I want to sue the driver that put me in this position in the first place and I want to report Progressive for Insurance Fraud.

4 years ago

I rented a ram truck and frequently drive in the area that , some one said I hit and ran … and now over a month has past and now a insurance co. Has now been calling me. They said there is a witness and a. The plate # which can be gotten at any any time…
What can. Or should I do… please send. HELP..